Enunciado
Why women have menopause
Menopause is when women stop being able to have babies. Toothed whales, like orcas, are one of the few animals that also experience menopause.
Normally, animals keep reproducing until they die. In humans and these whales, reproduction stops much earlier, leaving a longer period without having children. Some scientists wonder why this happens because it doesn’t seem to help survival or reproduction. One idea is that humans live much longer than before, but this doesn’t explain why whales also stop reproducing. Another idea is that childbirth at older ages can be dangerous, but research shows the risks are not high enough to explain menopause.
A more popular theory is the grandmother hypothesis. This suggests older females, like grandmothers, help their family by caring for grandchildren. This increases their chances of survival, so women should stop having children and focus on helping others.
Available at: https://www.newsinlevels.com/products/why-women-have-menopause-level-3/. Accessed on: Mar. 8th 2026.
What is the function of the extracts “this doesn’t explain why whales also stop reproducing” and “research shows the risks are not high enough to explain menopause”?
A)To explain why the two reasons for menopause presented are not well accepted.
B)To explain the reasons for menopause presented in more detail.
C)To give a popular opinion on the reasons for menopause presented.
D)To argue that the reasons presented are reasonable explanations for menopause.
Fonte: FUNDEP · FAME 2026/2 · Questões objetivas.
Questões objetivas
Ideia central: frases negativas podem mostrar limites de uma explicação.
“This doesn’t explain” aponta que a longevidade humana não explica o caso das baleias. “The risks are not high enough” indica que os riscos citados não bastam para explicar a menopausa. As duas frases enfraquecem as hipóteses anteriores.
Resposta: A. Elas não apenas detalham essas hipóteses nem as apresentam como explicações satisfatórias; mostram por que encontram dificuldades.